Categories: OLD Media Moves

Bethany McLean: Musk should be ashamed for criticizing reporter

CNBC’s Scott Wapner interviewed Linette Lopez, the Business Insider senior finance reporter whom CEO Elon Musk criticized over Twitter on her Tesla reporting, to respond to those comments.

Lopez denied, as Musk claimed, that she ever offered compensation to a Tesla whistleblower or provided insider information to short seller Jim Chanos, who has also criticized Tesla.

“I would prefer to talk about the reporting,” said Lopez. “It’s up to  shareholders to decide whether or not the CEO of a $50 billion company should spend his time yelling at reporters on Twitter.”

Chanos has denied receiving information from Lopez. Lopez added, “I don’t understand where Musk is getting these things. It’s unfortunate that he has to respond to this rather than what I say in my reporting.”

Vanity Fair reporter Bethany McLean, whose reporting of Enron was also criticized by the company, was also on the segment and said, “I think Musk should be ashamed of himself.”

She later added, “I’ve never understand this whole idea that somebody who reports bad news is biased and a CEO is somehow pure and unbiased.”

Yale University School of Management professor Jeffrey Sonnenfeld also was on the segment and stated,  “It’s beneath a CEO.”

Sonnenfeld said CEOs should simply speak the facts and not attack with innuendo.

To watch, go here.

Chris Roush

Chris Roush was the dean of the School of Communications at Quinnipiac University in Hamden, Connecticut. He was previously Walter E. Hussman Sr. Distinguished Professor in business journalism at UNC-Chapel Hill. He is a former business journalist for Bloomberg News, Businessweek, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, The Tampa Tribune and the Sarasota Herald-Tribune. He is the author of the leading business reporting textbook "Show me the Money: Writing Business and Economics Stories for Mass Communication" and "Thinking Things Over," a biography of former Wall Street Journal editor Vermont Royster.

View Comments

Recent Posts

CoinDesk journalists concerned about owner interference

Leo Schwartz of Fortune examines cryptocurrency news operation CoinDesk under its new owners, which forced editors…

2 hours ago

Western, formerly with WSJ, joins NY Times in Soeul

New York Times international editor Phil Pan sent out the following on Wednesday: We’re excited…

2 hours ago

NY Times names Karaian deputy biz editor

New York Times business editor Ellen Pollock sent out the following on Wednesday: I’m thrilled to announce…

2 hours ago

FT seeks a trade and climate correspondent

The Financial Times is looking for a correspondent to cover international trade, based in Washington,…

5 hours ago

Why hedge fund managers are hesitant to talk with reporters

Nell Mackenzie, a hedge fund reporter at Reuters, spoke on the "Hedge Fund Huddle" podcast…

9 hours ago

Fortune jumps to No. 8 biz news website in November

Fortune magazine jumped two spots to become the No. 8 business news website in November…

9 hours ago