OLD Media Moves

The use of “critics” and “experts” in the WSJ

William Power and Jennifer Hicks write in The Wall Street Journal Style & Substance blog that its reporters need to be more careful using the words “critics” and “experts.”

Power and Hicks write, “‘Critics and Experts’ sounds like the name of the worst Woody Allen movie, as our Editor in Chief Matt Murray cinematically puts it.

“In fact, they are two of The Wall Street Journal’s favorite catch-all terms, and that isn’t good. ‘They are broad and vague and often not backed up,’ says Matt. ‘Experts are sometimes self-appointed and sometimes of dubious provenance.’ And we use ‘critics’ as a device to summarize negative views, but without being specific as we should be.

“Every time we use those words, notes Matt, we are asking readers to believe we have done the work and that they should just trust us. Instead, always be specific—not just scientists but what kind? Not just critics but who? Instead of just experts, better to say market strategists or scientists who specialize in the area, or another specific phrase—and then name the people soon after in the article.

“And therein lies the second problem: Whether or not we like it, academia and think tanks are now often politicized, even as they often take pains to declare themselves as nonpartisan. But are you a straight-up nonpartisan band of experts just because you are attached to a university? Again, disclose and be specific. (And, as discussed before, describe think tanks and institutions including their leanings.)”

Read more here.

Chris Roush

Chris Roush was the dean of the School of Communications at Quinnipiac University in Hamden, Connecticut. He was previously Walter E. Hussman Sr. Distinguished Professor in business journalism at UNC-Chapel Hill. He is a former business journalist for Bloomberg News, Businessweek, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, The Tampa Tribune and the Sarasota Herald-Tribune. He is the author of the leading business reporting textbook "Show me the Money: Writing Business and Economics Stories for Mass Communication" and "Thinking Things Over," a biography of former Wall Street Journal editor Vermont Royster.

Recent Posts

Bloomberg hires Clark to cover VC and startups

Jillian Ward, managing editor for U.S. technology at Bloomberg News, sent the following note to…

4 mins ago

Berke of STAT News on the importance of its coverage

Rick Berke, a co-founded and executive editor of STAT News, writes about the importance of…

16 mins ago

Maxwell joins Gizmodo as a tech reporter

Thomas Maxwell has joined Gizmodo as a tech reporter. He previously was at Business Insider covering…

5 hours ago

Banking Times acquires The New Fiver

Banking Times has acquired the domain name "The New Fiver" for an undisclosed amount, aiming…

20 hours ago

Canadian Press hires Duggan as a reporter

The Canadian Press has hired Kyle Duggan as a reporter. Duggan has been an Ottawa-based reporter for…

1 day ago

Bloomberg Media launches Bloomberg Live Q&A

Bloomberg Media is starting a new service called Bloomberg Live Q&A, an audio-based platform that…

1 day ago