Categories: OLD Media Moves

"Firing" employees vs. "eliminating" them

The CEO of a manufacturing company in Wisconsin has written an opinion column for The Racine Journal Times because he was upset that the headline above a story in which his business terminated the jobs of 50 workers used the word “fired.”

David Rayburn, the CEO of Modine Manufacturing, wrote, “I was very disappointed to see the large headline in the newspaper on Friday, October 27, ‘Modine fires 50.’ These employees’ jobs were eliminated, based on a business decision, carried out after careful consideration. It was very insensitive to these employees’ hard work and service to characterize their situation in the sensational way you did.

“These employees are deservingly receiving career counseling and outplacement services in order to leverage their skills and find new employment. I have talked with several of them who were hurt and embarrassed by this headline, and worried about what it would do to their chances of getting a new job. I have also talked with current employees, retirees and members of the community who are angry and disappointed by the insensitivity of The Journal Times.

“Frankly, I think this headline shows your newspaper’s lack of understanding of the business climate and the challenges we all face.”

Read more here. And here is my comment: No matter how a company lets go of its workers, whether they are part of an “elimination” or a “reduction in force” or a “rightsizing” or a “downsizing” or any of the other euphemisms and corporate speak that companies use to make what they’ve done sound better, it’s still a firing or a “termination.”

A newspaper’s job is not to sugarcoat but to tell the truth. Get over it.

Next CNNMoney web site begins online video »

Previous « Business 2.0 rolls out blog beta

View Comments

asl says:
November 2, 2006 at 4:17 pm
Agree with you on this. GET OVER IT. I've had numerous companies complain about the word 'fire', when they tried any number of euphanisms: 'eliminate' `workforce reduction' `downsize' 'employee rationalization.'
Hey, i even argued that Delta's 'furloughed' pilots -- many of whom were never 'reinstated' were fired.
Bottom line is, when you go into work one day and summarily told you're not getting a check the next day, you've been fired.