Categories: OLD Media Moves

No way biz media could have predicted financial meltdown

Eric Starkman, who runs a public relations agency called Starkman & Associates, has an interested perspective on what’s wrong with the media world — it’s the leaders — but he also provides an interesting perspective on how the business media performed during the financial crisis.

Starkman writes, “Personally, I don’t buy into this notion that reporters should have been able to predict the financial meltdown.  It takes unabashed arrogance for journalists to believe that they are so well-steeped in economics and high finance that they can possibly forewarn the nation of a pending financial collapse.  They are on the sidelines, not in the game itself.

“Most business journalists tend to mime conventional wisdom of the day, which explains why the leaders of Enron, Worldcom, and Tyco were heralded in newspaper and magazine cover stories before those companies blew up.  Journalists would serve their audiences best if they reported as many informed perspectives as possible, rather than spew out their too often misinformed and biased opinions about the companies and subjects they supposedly objectively cover.

“As for the prescience of mainstream journalism about Goldman Sachs and Paulson, check out this fawning profile that Fortune published in 2004.”

Read more here.

View Comments

  • This guy is uninformed. Fortune also wrote extensive articles about the looming problem in the subprime market back circa 2005-2007; I had a reporter ask Bernie Ebbers in 2000 why his financial numbers didn't make sense, and Ebbers dismissed us as 'not understanding the WorldCom business model'-- and as soon as the earnings call ended, my reporter turned to me and said 'well, those guys are cooking up something.'

    Plenty of business reporters predicted the broad contours and basic truth of the financial crisis for years. But in a world awash in news, many people failed to notice. Starkman is one of them.

  • This would carry a lot more weight if Starkman weren't paid to help companies massage the truth and spin their images. Perhaps the problem isn't business journalists but the PR people paid to lie to them.

Recent Posts

Washington Post announces start of third newsroom

Washington Post executive editor Matt Murray sent out the following on Friday: Dear All, Over the last…

19 hours ago

FT hires Moens to cover competition and tech in Brussels

The Financial Times has hired Barbara Moens to cover competition and tech in Brussels. She will start…

20 hours ago

Deputy tech editor Haselton departs CNBC for The Verge

CNBC.com deputy technology editor Todd Haselton is leaving the news organization for a job at The Verge.…

20 hours ago

“Power Lunch” co-anchor Tyler Mathisen is leaving CNBC

Note from CNBC Business News senior vice president Dan Colarusso: After more than 27 years…

21 hours ago

Upset CoinDesk staffers send letter to owner

Members of the CoinDesk editorial team have sent a letter to the CEO of its…

23 hours ago

Capitol Forum seeks a deputy managing editor

The Capitol Forum is seeking a detail-oriented and collaborative Deputy Managing Editor to support the…

24 hours ago