No way biz media could have predicted financial meltdown
March 11, 2010
Eric Starkman, who runs a public relations agency called Starkman & Associates, has an interested perspective on what’s wrong with the media world — it’s the leaders — but he also provides an interesting perspective on how the business media performed during the financial crisis.
Starkman writes, “Personally, I don’t buy into this notion that reporters should have been able to predict the financial meltdown. It takes unabashed arrogance for journalists to believe that they are so well-steeped in economics and high finance that they can possibly forewarn the nation of a pending financial collapse. They are on the sidelines, not in the game itself.
“Most business journalists tend to mime conventional wisdom of the day, which explains why the leaders of Enron, Worldcom, and Tyco were heralded in newspaper and magazine cover stories before those companies blew up. Journalists would serve their audiences best if they reported as many informed perspectives as possible, rather than spew out their too often misinformed and biased opinions about the companies and subjects they supposedly objectively cover.
“As for the prescience of mainstream journalism about Goldman Sachs and Paulson, check out this fawning profile that Fortune published in 2004.”
OLD Media Moves
No way biz media could have predicted financial meltdown
March 11, 2010
Eric Starkman, who runs a public relations agency called Starkman & Associates, has an interested perspective on what’s wrong with the media world — it’s the leaders — but he also provides an interesting perspective on how the business media performed during the financial crisis.
Starkman writes, “Personally, I don’t buy into this notion that reporters should have been able to predict the financial meltdown. It takes unabashed arrogance for journalists to believe that they are so well-steeped in economics and high finance that they can possibly forewarn the nation of a pending financial collapse. They are on the sidelines, not in the game itself.
“Most business journalists tend to mime conventional wisdom of the day, which explains why the leaders of Enron, Worldcom, and Tyco were heralded in newspaper and magazine cover stories before those companies blew up. Journalists would serve their audiences best if they reported as many informed perspectives as possible, rather than spew out their too often misinformed and biased opinions about the companies and subjects they supposedly objectively cover.
“As for the prescience of mainstream journalism about Goldman Sachs and Paulson, check out this fawning profile that Fortune published in 2004.”
Read more here.
Media News
Carville wins WERT Prize for second time in three years
October 11, 2024
Media News
Macmillan wins Welles Prize
October 11, 2024
Media News
Slotnick departing The Points Guy
October 11, 2024
Media News
Fortune taps Smith to be US news chief
October 11, 2024
Media News
Galioto to cover the future of cities for Star Tribune
October 11, 2024
Subscribe to TBN
Receive updates about new stories in the industry daily or weekly.