Few economists in WSJ story on forecasting the economy
August 12, 2008
Hal Morris, writing on his Grumpy Editor blog, wants to know why there were only three economists in an article in today’s Wall Street Journal with the headline: “Economists expect 2008’s second half to be worse than the first.”
Morris writes, “Expecting to see input from a survey of 100 economists, or even 50, a close examination found economists from only three sources.
“Second paragraph from the end of the story inspired the headline with a senior economist at J. P. Morgan citing the effect of weak exports and then mentioning, ‘The bottom line is it’s going to be a weak second half.’
“Other input came from Goldman Sachs (unidentified) economists, who noted a contraction in consumer spending is likely over the second half and ‘the risk that foreign-demand weakness will wash back onto U.S. shores is clearly growing,’ and from a Global Insight economist who colorfully declared, ‘The air is coming out of the balloon pretty quickly here’ and ‘consumers are just throwing in the towel.’
“Also noted was declining recent activity at American Express Co., Talbots Inc., Kohl’s Corp. and Gap Inc.Â
“After reading the lengthy story, it’s almost like the WSJ seeks to curtail advertising from already shook-up businesses and sprinkle more alarm at consumers.”
OLD Media Moves
Few economists in WSJ story on forecasting the economy
August 12, 2008
Hal Morris, writing on his Grumpy Editor blog, wants to know why there were only three economists in an article in today’s Wall Street Journal with the headline: “Economists expect 2008’s second half to be worse than the first.”
“Second paragraph from the end of the story inspired the headline with a senior economist at J. P. Morgan citing the effect of weak exports and then mentioning, ‘The bottom line is it’s going to be a weak second half.’
“Other input came from Goldman Sachs (unidentified) economists, who noted a contraction in consumer spending is likely over the second half and ‘the risk that foreign-demand weakness will wash back onto U.S. shores is clearly growing,’ and from a Global Insight economist who colorfully declared, ‘The air is coming out of the balloon pretty quickly here’ and ‘consumers are just throwing in the towel.’
“Also noted was declining recent activity at American Express Co., Talbots Inc., Kohl’s Corp. and Gap Inc.Â
“After reading the lengthy story, it’s almost like the WSJ seeks to curtail advertising from already shook-up businesses and sprinkle more alarm at consumers.”
Read more here.
Media News
Forbes CEO: Stay focused on trusted journalism
August 12, 2026
Media News
Johansson hired as deputy editor of FT’s The Banker
August 12, 2026
Media News
Forbes fired top editor after discovering secret payment
August 12, 2026
Media News
What makes an M&A reporter stand out
August 12, 2026
Full-Time
Bloomberg seeks a prediction markets reporter
August 12, 2026
Subscribe to TBN
Receive updates about new stories in the industry daily or weekly.