TheStreet.com media critic Marek Fuchs writes Monday that business journalists have taken Citigroup’s statement that its earnings would return to normal next quarter hook, line and sinker.
Fuchs wrote, “On this subject, mark The Business Press Maven’s abnormally brilliant words: In announcing an oceanic write-off for the third quarter and entertaining no real questions on the matter in the process, Citigroup’s scripted, predigested and unchallenged assurances that “a return to normal earnings environment in the fourth quarter,” is in the offering. No matter how appetizing to bulls, this should be examined before swallowed.
“In a week in which the news from banks helped drive the stock market to new heights, Citigroup’s clever claim was, as is custom, reported by a business media operating in their default mode — as stenographers. We’ll review a few examples of the business media taking dictation from a company that wouldn’t even take their questions. Then we’ll get to the work of one particular journalist — Herb Greenberg — who guides you on how to truly regard the big, reeling bank’s pre-recorded words.
“Normal is as normal does for The Associated Press, who in their just-the-fact’s-ma’am mode was not able to do anything but regurgitate Citibank’s claim. They wrote:
‘The nation’s largest financial institution warned that third-quarter profit will fall because of subprime mortgage and credit market exposure, but said the current period should see a return to more normal earnings levels.'”
OLD Media Moves
Citigroup statement reported as fact
October 8, 2007
Posted by Chris Roush
TheStreet.com media critic Marek Fuchs writes Monday that business journalists have taken Citigroup’s statement that its earnings would return to normal next quarter hook, line and sinker.
Fuchs wrote, “On this subject, mark The Business Press Maven’s abnormally brilliant words: In announcing an oceanic write-off for the third quarter and entertaining no real questions on the matter in the process, Citigroup’s scripted, predigested and unchallenged assurances that “a return to normal earnings environment in the fourth quarter,” is in the offering. No matter how appetizing to bulls, this should be examined before swallowed.
“In a week in which the news from banks helped drive the stock market to new heights, Citigroup’s clever claim was, as is custom, reported by a business media operating in their default mode — as stenographers. We’ll review a few examples of the business media taking dictation from a company that wouldn’t even take their questions. Then we’ll get to the work of one particular journalist — Herb Greenberg — who guides you on how to truly regard the big, reeling bank’s pre-recorded words.
“Normal is as normal does for The Associated Press, who in their just-the-fact’s-ma’am mode was not able to do anything but regurgitate Citibank’s claim. They wrote:
Read more here.
Media News
Bloomberg Law hires Alafriz to cover insurance ligitation
May 6, 2024
Media News
Bloomberg Law hires Clason to cover health benefits
May 6, 2024
Media News
Hadi becomes chief deputy at NY Times biz department
May 6, 2024
Media News
NY Times’ Dreier, Reuters coverage of Musk win Pulitzers
May 6, 2024
Media News
Washington Biz Journal hires Peters to cover real estate
May 6, 2024
Subscribe to TBN
Receive updates about new stories in the industry daily or weekly.