Categories: OLD Media Moves

BusinessWeek cover story under attack

BusinessWeek’s latest cover story, about a new brat pack of young entrepreneurs in Silicon Valley, is being criticized by virtually everyone.

Former BusinessWeek reporter Gary Weiss, author of “Wall Street vs. America,” noted on his blog Friday that “Here’s the odd thing: the skepticism lacking in the story is actually right there at BW — just not in or near the article.

“In a BW Online blog, Rob Hof offers a dissenting voice: ‘As I’ve told Sarah [the author of the story], I’m still a little uncertain how different things really are now in the Valley. For every brash entrepreneur who can afford to blow off VCs, there are 100 more who would give their left, uh, knee to get a few mil for their startups.’

“It would have been nice if these countervailing sentiments were reflected in the article, or as an accompanying “sidebar,” and not stuck away in an online story comparatively few people will read.”

Meanwhile, Salon co-founder Scott Rosenberg blasts the headline on the cover, noting that the $60 million figure for Digg founder Kevin Rose is something pulled out of the air.

Rosenberg wrote, “Was it something that some irresponsible coverline writer had slapped on the piece, that the responsible writer was horrified to see? I don’t think so. The second paragraph of the article, referring to a recent redesign of the Digg site, reads: ‘At 29, Rose was on his way either to a cool $60 million or to total failure.’

“The $60 million number is never explained in the piece; the only real numbers are contained in this sentence: ‘So far, Digg is breaking even on an estimated $3 million annually in revenues. Nonetheless, people in the know say Digg is easily worth $200 million.’ Elsewhere the article says Rose owns 30 to 40 percent of the company. Hence, $60 million.

“There is a word for this kind of business journalism, and it is: awful. The reader has no idea who these ‘people in the know’ are; they could easily be people associated with the company who have an interest in inflating its worth.”

Meanwhile, the web site TechDirt has its own criticism of the story: “Suffice to say, BusinessWeek has written the ultimate Web2.0 hype piece without the slightest hint of skepticism about the numbers that it throws around. Digg very well may be sold at some point, and Kevin and the other Digg staff may make out very well. However, to suggest that they already have is pure bubble logic. Yeah, we’ve got some serious deja vu.”

Read more here.

View Comments

    Recent Posts

    Dynamo hires former Business Insider executive editor Harrington

    Former Business Insider executive editor Rebecca Harrington has been hired by Dynamo to be its…

    1 day ago

    Bloomberg TV hires Kerubo as desk producer

    Bloomberg Television has hired Brenda Kerubo as a desk producer in London. She will be covering Europe's…

    1 day ago

    Jittery CNBC staff reassured by new boss

    In a meeting at CNBC headquarters Thursday afternoon, incoming boss Mark Lazarus presented a bullish…

    1 day ago

    Making business news accessible to a wider audience

    Ritika Gupta, the BBC's North American business correspondent, was interviewed by Global Woman magazine about…

    1 day ago

    Rest of World hires Lo as China reporter

    Rest of World has hired Kinling Lo as a China reporter. Lo was previously a…

    1 day ago

    Bloomberg rises to No. 7 biz news website

    Bloomberg News saw strong unique visitor growth to its website in October, passing Fox Business…

    1 day ago