Categories: OLD Media Moves

Biz media didn’t do enough in covering stimulus

The financial media focused too much on covering the political aspects of the federal government’s stimulus package aimed at the economic crisis during 2009 and didn’t do enough agenda setting, according to research from a Columbia University professor.

“Much of the coverage focused on the political process and the familiar debates about tax cuts and protectionism and so came across as fairly pedestrian and predictable,” wrote Anya Schiffrin, director of the media and communications program at Columbia’s School of International and Public Affairs. “Partly due to the short nature of many of the articles, there was little deep analysis and the press did not do very much to advance the debate or lay out a new agenda for discussion.”

Schiffrin’s research, published in the latest issue of the peer-reviewed journal “Journalism: Theory, Practice and Criticism,” reviewed press coverage of the economic stimulus package from Jan. 2 to March 5, 2009 and then from July 1to Sept. 1, 2009. She chose those periods to look at coverage before the American Assistance and Recovery Act was passed on Feb. 16 and then a few months later to see how coverage had changed.

Schiffrin and master’s student Ryan Fagan reviewed more than 700 articles, columns and editorials from 16 different sources, including major business news publications such as Barron’s, Bloomberg, Businessweek, Dow Jones, Fortune, The Financial Times, Reuters and The Wall Street Journal.

With the columns and editorials, the research discovered that the New York Times was the biggest supporter of the stimulus package while the Journal was the biggest opponent. More than 60 percent of the columns and editorials reviewed had a negative bias toward the legislature, but in the Times that percentage was just 30 percent. In The Journal, the percentage of columns and editorials with a negative bias toward the legislature was 94 percent.

The research also reviewed the sources being used in the articles and discovered that more than three-fourths of the 576 articles quoted government officials, while just 14.7 percent quoted economists and just 4.7 percent quoted people in the public or organizations that represent the public. More than one-fifth of the articles quoted someone from a business or the financial markets.

The wire services — Bloomberg, Dow Jones and Reuters — quoted a higher percentage of business/financial markets sources and a lower percentage of government officials. The daily financial papers — The Journal and the Financial Times — quoted more economists than the average.

“In retrospect, the coverage of the politics, the economics, and the debate of the bill did not raise the issues that should have been central to the policy debate in 2008, and deficiencies in coverage then may have contributed to weaknesses in the subsequent policy discussion,” wrote Schiffrin.

To read her entire article, go here.

Chris Roush

Chris Roush was the dean of the School of Communications at Quinnipiac University in Hamden, Connecticut. He was previously Walter E. Hussman Sr. Distinguished Professor in business journalism at UNC-Chapel Hill. He is a former business journalist for Bloomberg News, Businessweek, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, The Tampa Tribune and the Sarasota Herald-Tribune. He is the author of the leading business reporting textbook "Show me the Money: Writing Business and Economics Stories for Mass Communication" and "Thinking Things Over," a biography of former Wall Street Journal editor Vermont Royster.

Recent Posts

Is this the end of CoinDesk as we know it?

Former CoinDesk editorial staffer Michael McSweeney writes about the recent happenings at the cryptocurrency news site, where…

7 hours ago

LinkedIn finance editor Singh departs

Manas Pratap Singh, finance editor for LinkedIn News Europe, has left for a new opportunity…

1 day ago

Washington Post announces start of third newsroom

Washington Post executive editor Matt Murray sent out the following on Friday: Dear All, Over the last…

2 days ago

FT hires Moens to cover competition and tech in Brussels

The Financial Times has hired Barbara Moens to cover competition and tech in Brussels. She will start…

2 days ago

Deputy tech editor Haselton departs CNBC for The Verge

CNBC.com deputy technology editor Todd Haselton is leaving the news organization for a job at The Verge.…

2 days ago

“Power Lunch” co-anchor Tyler Mathisen is leaving CNBC

Note from CNBC Business News senior vice president Dan Colarusso: After more than 27 years…

2 days ago