A South African business editor on financial journalism’s failure
September 29, 2020
Posted by Chris Roush
Lukanyo Mnyanda, the editor of Business Day in South Africa, writes about why business journalism has failed society.
Mnyanda writes, “Financial journalists attract criticism for their lack of investigative skills, as opposed to simply reporting on and analysing financial and other calendar events. They might, with the help of analysts, be good at analysing the financial implications of an M&A transaction that’s been announced but are less likely to come up with groundbreaking investigations of their own.
“So while the lack of accounting and forensic skills, which might otherwise have enabled them to see a Steinhoff coming, is bad enough, due to the nature of newsrooms nowadays they lack the relationships with people in companies that might give them access to potential whistle-blowers.
“News doesn’t happen in the newsroom, the saying goes. And very few potential sources of information that expose wrongdoing will share it, at potentially great personal risk, with people they don’t know. That’s not to say we should give up on journalists’ role as watchdogs. As a society we should decide how much value we place on it. Consumers demand it from journalists, but aren’t willing to pay for news.”
OLD Media Moves
A South African business editor on financial journalism’s failure
September 29, 2020
Posted by Chris Roush
Mnyanda writes, “Financial journalists attract criticism for their lack of investigative skills, as opposed to simply reporting on and analysing financial and other calendar events. They might, with the help of analysts, be good at analysing the financial implications of an M&A transaction that’s been announced but are less likely to come up with groundbreaking investigations of their own.
“So while the lack of accounting and forensic skills, which might otherwise have enabled them to see a Steinhoff coming, is bad enough, due to the nature of newsrooms nowadays they lack the relationships with people in companies that might give them access to potential whistle-blowers.
“News doesn’t happen in the newsroom, the saying goes. And very few potential sources of information that expose wrongdoing will share it, at potentially great personal risk, with people they don’t know. That’s not to say we should give up on journalists’ role as watchdogs. As a society we should decide how much value we place on it. Consumers demand it from journalists, but aren’t willing to pay for news.”
Read more here.
Media News
Bloomberg issues travel warning to editorial staff
April 21, 2025
Media News
CNN hires Freedman as senior reporter
April 21, 2025
Full-Time
Business Insider seeks a weekend editor in London
April 20, 2025
Media News
The National hires Bloomberg’s Cranny
April 20, 2025
Full-Time
The Real Deal seeks a reporter in Los Angeles
April 19, 2025
Subscribe to TBN
Receive updates about new stories in the industry daily or weekly.