Categories: OLD Media Moves

Why News Corp. needs to hold on to All Things D

Felix Salmon of Reuters writes why it is important for News Corp. to hang on to its All Things D tech news website run by journalists Kara Swisher and Walt Mossberg.

Salmon writes, “What’s happened here is that Swisher and Mossberg have created something with substantial value — as much as $50 million. And since the value lies with them, rather than in the ATD brand, they can walk away and find a strategic partner willing to invest an eight-figure sum in creating a new, entirely independent brand. That’s got to be attractive to them, for two reasons: firstly, they would become truly independent, and in control of their own destiny. No more begging their New York paymasters for extra investment: if they own the company, they can make all those decisions themselves. And then, of course, there’s the money: if they each own say 25% of a $50 million company, that’s a lot of paper wealth which they’re never going to accumulate working for News Corp, and which — in the way of Silicon Valley — could become worth much more still if their expansion plans work out the way they hope they will.

“Meanwhile, Rupert Murdoch stands firmly on the other side of the Great Paywall Divide, and feels as a matter of principle that all of his properties (except, perhaps, nypost.com) should charge readers for their content. He’s also human, which means that, like all other humans, he’s deeply reluctant to pay a large amount of money to buy something he already owns.

“Murdoch, by rights, should be able to retain control of ATD, complete with Swisher and Mossberg. They’re offering very little to his rivals: a minority stake, no editorial control whatsoever, and probably very little cashflow, at least for the first few years, since as a startup they’re going to want to reinvest all of their revenues back into their company. Meanwhile, News Corp has the opportunity to own ATD 100% (indeed, it already does), and can offer Swisher and Mossberg the ability to invest in the site without having to go through the hassles of rebranding and relaunching. Given the economics of control premiums, Murdoch should easily be able to promise significantly more resources than his rivals can come up with.

“But after years of writing the entrepreneurial gospel, it’s understandable that Swisher and Mossberg might want to live it for themselves. And they’re both wealthy enough to afford a few years of startup wages: Mossberg has been one of Murdoch’s highest-paid print journalists for years, while Swisher, who’s well paid herself, is also married to long-time Google executive Megan Smith.”

Read more here.

Chris Roush

Chris Roush was the dean of the School of Communications at Quinnipiac University in Hamden, Connecticut. He was previously Walter E. Hussman Sr. Distinguished Professor in business journalism at UNC-Chapel Hill. He is a former business journalist for Bloomberg News, Businessweek, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, The Tampa Tribune and the Sarasota Herald-Tribune. He is the author of the leading business reporting textbook "Show me the Money: Writing Business and Economics Stories for Mass Communication" and "Thinking Things Over," a biography of former Wall Street Journal editor Vermont Royster.

View Comments

    Recent Posts

    Pacific Business News hires Meierdiercks as editor in chief

    The Pacific Business News, an American City Business Journals publication, has hired Janis Magin Meierdiercks  as…

    21 hours ago

    Sifted reporter Nowshin departs

    Sadia Nowshin, a reporter at European startup news site Sifted, is leaving to join literary…

    21 hours ago

    Variety promotes Shanfeld to TV reporter

    Variety has promoted Ethan Shanfeld to TV reporter. William Earl of Variety writes, "Shanfeld joins the entertainment…

    21 hours ago

    Klimasinska named Bloomberg’s DC breaking news team leader

    Kasia Klimasinska is the new team leader for DC breaking news at Bloomberg News. She…

    23 hours ago

    NYC event to honor Ledbetter is next week

      Paul Smalera has organized a gathering of James Ledbetter's friends and colleagues—open to all…

    1 day ago

    CoStar hires Scheier to cover San Francisco market

    Real estate news service CoStar News has hired Rachel Scheier to cover the San Francisco commercial market.…

    1 day ago