Categories: OLD Media Moves

Watchdog financial journalism is nearly 200 years old

One of the continuing arguments about the quality of financial journalism is that in the past it wasn’t as tough as it should be in uncovering unscrupulous companies and fraud.

However, new research by a British professor — James Taylor of Lancaster University — shows that the financial press during the Victorian era played a more active role in exposing and reporting fraud than what has been previously thought, lending credence to the argument that business journalism has a long history of serving as a corporate watchdog.

Taylor’s work, published earlier this week by the Institute of Historical Research at the University of London, focuses on coverage of the Independent and West Middlesex Fire an Life Assurance Company, which was exposed as a Ponzi scheme 80 years before the Boston media discovered Charles Ponzi. The company collapsed in 1841, and its executives disappeared, after critical coverage

“No reader of the nineteenth-century press can fail to be struck by the sheer volume of coverage given to the subject of white-collar crime,” writes Taylor.

Taylor notes that some British newspapers did not write laudatory articles about the insurance company, which was a large advertiser in its issues. But many papers did examine its operations, including one — the Scotch Reformers’ Gazette — that hired detectives to investigate the company and then ran a series of articles in 1839 based on what was discovered.

The insurer tried to quiet some of the journalists by offering bribes, which were refused. It also began libel proceedings against some papers. But after The Times sent a clerk to its offices to collect payment on an advertising bill and found the office empty in early 1841, most of the London papers wrote extensively about the company’s demise.

By 1843, after exhausting its investigation into the insurer, writes Taylor, “There is evidence that the mainstream London press was already beginning to envision a more active role for itself in tackling company fraud.”

He found stories that called companies “a worthless bubble” and a “jobbing company.” The Times became especially aggressive, found Taylor.

“In the aftermath of the I.W.M., London’s financial journalists staked a claim to respectability and status not so much on the strength of their knowledge, their contacts or their literacy skills, but on their willingness to expose fraud,” concluded Taylor.

I’ve long argued that there’s plenty of evidence that business journalism in the United States has been a watchdog for much longer than people are willing to admit, dating back to Ida Tarbell’s writing about the Standard Oil Co. in the first decade of the 20th century and Henry Demarest Lloyd’s writing in the Chicago Tribune in the 1870s about robber barons.

Taylor’s research pushes the beginning of watchdog financial journalism back to an even earlier time.

Chris Roush

Chris Roush was the dean of the School of Communications at Quinnipiac University in Hamden, Connecticut. He was previously Walter E. Hussman Sr. Distinguished Professor in business journalism at UNC-Chapel Hill. He is a former business journalist for Bloomberg News, Businessweek, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, The Tampa Tribune and the Sarasota Herald-Tribune. He is the author of the leading business reporting textbook "Show me the Money: Writing Business and Economics Stories for Mass Communication" and "Thinking Things Over," a biography of former Wall Street Journal editor Vermont Royster.

Recent Posts

Is this the end of CoinDesk as we know it?

Former CoinDesk editorial staffer Michael McSweeney writes about the recent happenings at the cryptocurrency news site, where…

3 hours ago

LinkedIn finance editor Singh departs

Manas Pratap Singh, finance editor for LinkedIn News Europe, has left for a new opportunity…

1 day ago

Washington Post announces start of third newsroom

Washington Post executive editor Matt Murray sent out the following on Friday: Dear All, Over the last…

2 days ago

FT hires Moens to cover competition and tech in Brussels

The Financial Times has hired Barbara Moens to cover competition and tech in Brussels. She will start…

2 days ago

Deputy tech editor Haselton departs CNBC for The Verge

CNBC.com deputy technology editor Todd Haselton is leaving the news organization for a job at The Verge.…

2 days ago

“Power Lunch” co-anchor Tyler Mathisen is leaving CNBC

Note from CNBC Business News senior vice president Dan Colarusso: After more than 27 years…

2 days ago