Categories: OLD Media Moves

TV business editor livid at GM’s tactics

Rod Meloni, Local 4 business editor in Detroit, wrote Tuesday about General Motors Co. has attempted to control coverage of its growing recall by only inviting print media to a news conference.

Meloni writes, “GM invited only 10 print reporters to the GM Ren Cen headquarters for a press briefing with Mary Barra. Tightly-controlled, hand-picked reporters were there. The usual gang that could be counted on to ask questions that would not shock or otherwise fluster the new CEO. CNBC’s Phil LeBeau was invited to listen in on the phone as Mary Barra talked about the biggest crisis at GM since its bankruptcy. It was nut cutting time at the Ren Cen and instead of having the nation’s broadcasters, or the local broadcasters who talk with their shareholders and employees every night, they chose to just go with the arm’s length print medium.

“In thinking back to the GM bankruptcy, CEO Rick Wagoner, as beleaguered as he was, would stand up and answer every question at press conferences that included every manner of reporter and camera. GM was in crisis, it was looking for a handout that it eventually received from the federal government and Wagoner took the public beating he so richly deserved. He was the multi-millionaire executive, his desk was where the buck stopped and he knew he had no choice but to be held accountable. That’s how it is supposed to work. It was unpleasant, but Wagoner stood up before shareholders, employees and the nation to answer the toughest questions in the full light of day. No coddling there.

“Fast forward five years and the new media handlers around Mary Barra believe she is too delicate a flower for that. In her honeymoon period as the top executive, proud to acknowledge her salary will eclipse $12 million this year, a woman who is highly touted as a GM lifer who has been through and seen a lot is somehow and for inexplicable reasons being held back from the true test of her leadership: true accountability in the sunshine. They and GM’s attorneys obviously believe she is either too new or inexperienced to answer questions on camera with all those pesky bright lights. The tightly controlled and amateur looking video of Mary Barra GM put out yesterday appears the most the management and media relations seem to be able to live with. Ladies and gentlemen the building is burning! What in the world is going on here?”

Read more here.

Chris Roush

Chris Roush was the dean of the School of Communications at Quinnipiac University in Hamden, Connecticut. He was previously Walter E. Hussman Sr. Distinguished Professor in business journalism at UNC-Chapel Hill. He is a former business journalist for Bloomberg News, Businessweek, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, The Tampa Tribune and the Sarasota Herald-Tribune. He is the author of the leading business reporting textbook "Show me the Money: Writing Business and Economics Stories for Mass Communication" and "Thinking Things Over," a biography of former Wall Street Journal editor Vermont Royster.

View Comments

    Recent Posts

    Onanuga joins Yahoo Finance UK as homepage editor

    Business Insider's Tola Onanuga has joined Yahoo Finance in the United Kingdom as its homepage editor. She…

    9 hours ago

    Temperton joins Logic as deputy ME

    The Logic managing editor Jordan Timm sent out the following: I’m excited to announce that James…

    9 hours ago

    Upstate Biz Journal unveils redesign

    The Upstate Business Journal in South Carolina has rolled out a redesign. Sherry Jackson, vice…

    2 days ago

    STAT News taps Lawrence to cover the FDA

    STAT News has named Lizzy Lawrence its FDA reporter, leading coverage of the preeminent food…

    2 days ago

    Dallas Morning News seeks a breaking biz news reporter

    The Dallas Morning News is searching for an intrepid and curious breaking news business reporter…

    2 days ago

    BBC hires Marketplace’s Jamali as tech correspondent

    BBC has hired Lily Jamali as its North America tech correspondent, based in San Francisco.…

    2 days ago