Slate.com media critic Jack Shafer responds to comments made by former Wall Street Journal managing editor Paul Steiger that the paper’s new owner, Rupert Murdoch, hasn’t hurt it yet are just an indication that he’s unaware of how Murdoch subtly gets what he wants.
Shafer writes, “Murdoch would no more make a policy of twisting Wall Street Journal coverage to News Corp.’s benefit than he would of publishing women in the buff on its Page 3. As anybody who has read a profile or biography of the genocidal tyrantknows,he can be either subtle or obvious in the way he flexes his publications’ power.
“In a May 2007 Portfolio.com piece, Felix Salmon described Murdoch’s modus operandi perfectly: ‘[W]here editorial independence is valuable, Murdoch values it. Where it isn’t, he doesn’t.’
“To expand on Salmon’s observation, Murdoch values the Journal‘s editorial independence because he knows it is the paper’s primary asset. Without the reader trust that editorial independence has created, the paper would go bust in a year. Salmon explains that Murdoch is free to muck about with Fox News, the New York Post, the Sun, and other less prestigious appendages in his media domain because their regular readers and viewers don’t care. These outlets are stink-proof.”
OLD Media Moves
Steiger doesn't have a clue how Murdoch operates
July 26, 2008
Slate.com media critic Jack Shafer responds to comments made by former Wall Street Journal managing editor Paul Steiger that the paper’s new owner, Rupert Murdoch, hasn’t hurt it yet are just an indication that he’s unaware of how Murdoch subtly gets what he wants.
“In a May 2007 Portfolio.com piece, Felix Salmon described Murdoch’s modus operandi perfectly: ‘[W]here editorial independence is valuable, Murdoch values it. Where it isn’t, he doesn’t.’
“To expand on Salmon’s observation, Murdoch values the Journal‘s editorial independence because he knows it is the paper’s primary asset. Without the reader trust that editorial independence has created, the paper would go bust in a year. Salmon explains that Murdoch is free to muck about with Fox News, the New York Post, the Sun, and other less prestigious appendages in his media domain because their regular readers and viewers don’t care. These outlets are stink-proof.”
Read more here.
Media News
The Wrap hires Loving as a reporter
June 16, 2026
Full-Time
9fin seeks a leveraged finance reporter
June 16, 2026
Media News
Fortune hires Tejera as a video producer
June 16, 2026
Media News
Bloomberg hires Foster as personal finance reporter
June 16, 2026
Media News
Washington Biz Journal publisher Orfinger resigns
June 16, 2026
Subscribe to TBN
Receive updates about new stories in the industry daily or weekly.