Categories: OLD Media Moves

SCOTUS limits range of FOIA requests made by news outlets

The Supreme Court ruled in favor of retailers seeking to prevent a South Dakota newspaper from obtaining store-level data on the redemption of food stamp benefits. | Alex Wong/Getty Images

The Supreme Court placed a new limit on the reach of FOIA requests made by news outlets in its Monday ruling in Food Marketing Institute v. Argus Leader Media.

In the matter, the Argus Leader, a South Dakota newspaper, sought to compel the disclosure of store-level data on the redemption of government benefits by filing a FOIA request with the Department of Agriculture. The newspaper sought the names and addresses of retail stores that participate in the national food-stamp program, now officially known as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program.

An industry group sued on behalf of the government, seeking to keep the records confidential. The Court sided with the industry group.

From Politico:

The high court ruling rejected a half-century-old appeals court precedent that allowed the withholding of business records under the Freedom of Information Act only in cases where harm would result either to the business or to the government’s ability to acquire information in the future. …

Business groups had urged the high court to strike down the longstanding precedent. News organizations and open-government advocates pleaded with the justices to leave it in place.

Democratic appointee Justice Elena Kagan joined the Court’s five conservatives in the opinion. Three justices — Stephen Breyer, Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Sonia Sotomayor — partially dissented.

Erica Thompson

Recent Posts

CNN Underscored seeks a senior money editor

The Senior Money Editor will be responsible for content creation and strategy for money and personal finance recommendation and…

6 hours ago

Reporter Witt departs Wichita Biz Journal

Josh Witt, a reporter at the Wichita Business Journal, is leaving the American City Business…

2 days ago

Business Insider names Sommers interim UK bureau chief

Business Insider has named Jack Sommers its interim UK bureau chief. He has been a deputy editor…

2 days ago

WFMZ-TV in Allentown seeks a business reporter

WFMZ-TV is seeking a dynamic Business Reporter with a passion for reporting and an ability…

2 days ago

CNBC is expanding its sports business coverage

CNBC is throwing its weight behind its nascent CNBC Sport brand, bringing its sports business coverage to…

2 days ago

How right-leaning outlets have covered the market sell-off

Ken Bensinger of The New York Times writes about how right-leaning media organizations have not emphasized…

2 days ago