Categories: OLD Media Moves

Professor studies stock price changes and business journalism

Michael Blanding of the Tuck business school at Dartmouth writes about the research of visiting professor Diego Garcia, who examines the relationship between stock price movements and how they are written about in the financial press.

Blanding writes, “‘Journalists do not make much out of positive returns in the market,’ says Garcia. ‘On very good days, they don’t seem very upbeat. On the other hand, on bad days they really play up the bad returns.’ Even more surprisingly, Garcia found that the negative spin by columnists can have a downward effect on the market. ‘You could almost trade on it,’ says Garcia. ‘If you are a hedge fund manager, you could read the paper in the morning and just by doing what it says, become a millionaire.’

“But don’t get rid of your financial adviser just yet. Garcia uncovered these novel links between news and the stock market in an exhaustive search across historical newspaper columns covering a century. ‘When the New York Times historical archives first came online, I was looking them over out of curiosity and realized a number of columns were printed almost daily since the early 1900s,’ he says. ‘Then the Wall Street Journal archives start in 1920. I thought this could be an interesting dataset.’

“He took several columns from the Times, namely ‘Financial Markets’ and ‘Topics in Wall-Street,’ along with the ‘Abreast of the Market’ column from the Journal, and electronically ‘read’ every copy of them between 1905 and 2005. By “reading” he means that, using dictionaries from psychology, he counted the number of positive and negative words in each story, and compared the daily totals to the Dow Jones Industrial Average each day.

“When he did so, he found that the when the market dropped from a return of +1 percent to -1 percent, the columnists used 1.5 times as many negative words the following day (rising to 3 percent of total words from 2 percent). When the market dropped from -1 percent to -3 percent, it added another percentage point of negative words, bringing the total to 4 percent, or twice as many negative words as on average.”

Read more here.

Chris Roush

Chris Roush was the dean of the School of Communications at Quinnipiac University in Hamden, Connecticut. He was previously Walter E. Hussman Sr. Distinguished Professor in business journalism at UNC-Chapel Hill. He is a former business journalist for Bloomberg News, Businessweek, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, The Tampa Tribune and the Sarasota Herald-Tribune. He is the author of the leading business reporting textbook "Show me the Money: Writing Business and Economics Stories for Mass Communication" and "Thinking Things Over," a biography of former Wall Street Journal editor Vermont Royster.

View Comments

    Recent Posts

    FT taps Foy to cover European banking

    Financial Times reporter Simon Foy is now covering European banks. He has been covering accounting for the…

    11 mins ago

    Debtwire seeks a private credit reporter

    Debtwire, the leading provider of global fixed income news, analysis and data for more than…

    3 hours ago

    BNN Bloomberg anchor Kanwar is departing

    Amber Kanwar, an anchor for BNN Bloomberg in Canada, is departing at the end of…

    3 hours ago

    Moody’s promotes Kantrow to editor in chief

    Moody's Ratings has promoted Yvette Kantrow to senior vice president and editor in chief. She has been…

    3 hours ago

    Politico reporter Fieseler departs

    Politico reporter Clare Fieseler is leaving the news organization to take on some ocean reporting projects. She…

    3 hours ago

    WSJ’s Eisen to write book about the mortgage market

    Wall Street Journal reporter Ben Eisen has signed a contract with Norton to write a book about…

    6 hours ago