Categories: OLD Media Moves

Lipman to blame for Portfolio's failure

Paul Smalera, a former Conde Nast Portfolio staffer, writes on Gawker that the business magazine’s demise rests solely on the shoulders of editor Joanne Lipman.

Smalera writes, “Yet in too many ways to enumerate here, we did not operate in what I fondly call a reality-based environment. In Lipman’s meetings, firings were never firings, stories were never bad or ill timed, mistakes were never made. The air had long been sucked out of that room, and few staffers seemed to believe anymore in the mission of the place, despite a collective desire, and I mean this, to do as good a job as they could do, given the circumstances.

“Early in my time there, I saw a Deputy Editor I learned from and respected be run out on a rail for his insouciance, his belief that the magazine could be a great thing. I wondered, as those early undercurrents of dissent began to swell, why no one was pointing out the empress had no clothes. Wasn’t this journalism, capital J? Didn’t it matter when seasoned vets thought we were going about things in a haphazard, disjointed, unfocused and fundamentally wrong way? Yes, but. These were also jobs, capital J. And as is now clear, no one, inside or out, was ever going to save Lipman from herself.

“And who knows, as her faltering became apparent, what kind of pressures Lipman faced from her boss, and his boss, and Newhouse himself, that further distorted the title? Essentially, it’s hard to take principled stands when you work pretty much at the beneficence of a billionaire. And if you’re wondering what’s wrong with journalism these days, that’s pretty much it.”

Read more here.

Recent Posts

Zeballos-Roig departs Semafor after two years

Semafor economic policy reporter Joseph Zeballos-Roig has left the organization after two years. He previously…

2 mins ago

Inc.’s Hofman on focusing on entrepreneurs

Russell Sherman of the "Press Profiles" podcast interviewed Mike Hofman, the editor in chief of…

5 mins ago

Dow Jones names new tech leaders

Dow Jones chief technology officer Artem Fishman sent out the following: Team, As we continue…

57 mins ago

Yahoo Finance seeks an executive producer

Yahoo Finance is the world's most-used business and financial digital platform. It offers millions of…

3 hours ago

Entertainment industry reporter Voytko-Best departs Forbes

Lisette Voytko-Best, who covered the entertainment industry for Forbes, has left the publication. Voytko-Best is…

5 hours ago

Dow Jones hires Hancock to cover antitrust in Europe

The Wall Street Journal and Dow Jones have hired Edith Hancock to cover antitrust and competition issues…

6 hours ago