TheStreet.com media critic Marek Fuchs writes Wednesday that business news stories about Cisco’s recent earnings have the company meeting analyst expectations — but only because the company lowered expectations, which isn’t mentioned or buried in most stories.
Fuchs writes, “Revenue was also ‘jumping’ at TheStreet.com, which wrote that the $9.8 billion, came in ‘slightly above Wall Street’s estimate of $9.75 billion.’ Technically true, but you have to read down three paragraphs to get the meaningful caveat. Snooze and you lose:
‘Traders had been on edge after Chambers reduced expectations for revenue in the fiscal third quarter. On the company’s last conference call, Chambers cut Cisco’s fiscal third-quarter guidance to 10% growth, down from the 15% previously expected.’
“Read The San Jose Mercury News and it’s as if the company never lowered top line expectations. Here’s the headline, ‘Positive numbers for Cisco: GROWTH FOR QUARTER EXCEEDS EXPECTATIONS’ and here’s the lead: ‘Cisco Systems, often considered a bellwether for the health of the technology sector, reported third-quarter growth on Tuesday that exceeded expectations.’
“True enough on the profit side. But that revenue? The way the company ratcheted them down only three months ago? Is it mentioned anywhere in the body of the article? No.”
OLD Media Moves
Biz media fails to meet analyst expectations
May 7, 2008
TheStreet.com media critic Marek Fuchs writes Wednesday that business news stories about Cisco’s recent earnings have the company meeting analyst expectations — but only because the company lowered expectations, which isn’t mentioned or buried in most stories.
Fuchs writes, “Revenue was also ‘jumping’ at TheStreet.com, which wrote that the $9.8 billion, came in ‘slightly above Wall Street’s estimate of $9.75 billion.’ Technically true, but you have to read down three paragraphs to get the meaningful caveat. Snooze and you lose:
“Read The San Jose Mercury News and it’s as if the company never lowered top line expectations. Here’s the headline, ‘Positive numbers for Cisco: GROWTH FOR QUARTER EXCEEDS EXPECTATIONS’ and here’s the lead: ‘Cisco Systems, often considered a bellwether for the health of the technology sector, reported third-quarter growth on Tuesday that exceeded expectations.’
“True enough on the profit side. But that revenue? The way the company ratcheted them down only three months ago? Is it mentioned anywhere in the body of the article? No.”
Read more here.
Media News
SABEW elects new board members, Nelson as president
April 24, 2024
Media News
WSJ receives first Peabody Award nomination
April 24, 2024
Media News
NAHJ seeks to start biz journalism task force
April 24, 2024
Media News
Bagchee returning to CNBC to run international
April 24, 2024
Media News
Hillman Prizes awarded to Quartz, Bloomberg Businessweek
April 24, 2024
Subscribe to TBN
Receive updates about new stories in the industry daily or weekly.