Criticism in tech writing has become overly pessimistic, writes Nausicaa Renner of the Columbia Journalism Review.
Renner writes, “In a recent report, Tow Fellow Sara Watson counters the narrative that criticism has to be pessimistic. There is a lot of room, she argues, for thoughtful criticism that lands somewhere between ominous narratives written by luddites and the latest gadget review, noting that this type of constructive tech criticism has the potential to shape the discourse and future of tech.
“Constructive criticism, Watson writes, ‘skews toward optimism, or at least toward an idea that future technological societies could be improved.’ By meeting readers in their daily experience of technology, it offers ‘tools and framings for thinking about their relationship to technology and their relationship to power. Beyond intellectual arguments, constructive criticism…offers frameworks for living with technology.’
“Technology writers have a great opportunity to collaborate with engineers and the like to shape the future of tech, rather than portray it as corrosive to humanity. As technology is increasingly integrated into our lives, the work of both the journalist and the critic to document and direct it. The idea isn’t to upend the hard-won skills of balance and reporting. It’s to see criticism as a constructive part of the reporting process, a way for journalists and others to contribute, not just to gadget reviews but to a robust sense of technology, how people use it, and how it could be better.”
OLD Media Moves
Hey tech writers, lighten up on the criticism
October 13, 2016
Posted by Chris Roush
Criticism in tech writing has become overly pessimistic, writes Nausicaa Renner of the Columbia Journalism Review.
Renner writes, “In a recent report, Tow Fellow Sara Watson counters the narrative that criticism has to be pessimistic. There is a lot of room, she argues, for thoughtful criticism that lands somewhere between ominous narratives written by luddites and the latest gadget review, noting that this type of constructive tech criticism has the potential to shape the discourse and future of tech.
“Constructive criticism, Watson writes, ‘skews toward optimism, or at least toward an idea that future technological societies could be improved.’ By meeting readers in their daily experience of technology, it offers ‘tools and framings for thinking about their relationship to technology and their relationship to power. Beyond intellectual arguments, constructive criticism…offers frameworks for living with technology.’
“Technology writers have a great opportunity to collaborate with engineers and the like to shape the future of tech, rather than portray it as corrosive to humanity. As technology is increasingly integrated into our lives, the work of both the journalist and the critic to document and direct it. The idea isn’t to upend the hard-won skills of balance and reporting. It’s to see criticism as a constructive part of the reporting process, a way for journalists and others to contribute, not just to gadget reviews but to a robust sense of technology, how people use it, and how it could be better.”
Read more here.
Full-Time
FT seeks a reporter for its Unhedged newsletter
April 18, 2024
Media News
Wu departing FT for The Economist
April 18, 2024
Media News
Morning Brew hires McGrath to cover health care
April 18, 2024
Media News
BBC News hires Labiak as a biz reporter
April 18, 2024
Full-Time
Bloomberg Law seeks a privacy reporter
April 18, 2024
Subscribe to TBN
Receive updates about new stories in the industry daily or weekly.