Business journalist Gary Weiss wonders on his blog why Overstock.com CEO Patrick Byrne, a frequent critic of business journalism, is used as a source for stories.
Weiss writes, “One really has to wonder what motivated the Salt Lake City Tribune, in this story, to buttonhole Byrne of all people to pontificate on corporate management of earnings releases. It’s just embarassing. Good heavens, a little elementary research would have found ample material on the web on how Byrne has engineered earnings at Overstock, much of it by white collar crime-fighter Sam Antar.
“For instance, Antar pointed out in some detail in his blog last year how Byrne manipulated the earnings announcement in the first quarter of 2008.
“While the Trib’s sloppiness is not comparable with the atrocious media coverage of Pegasus Wireless or Biovail, it’s the kind of thing that erodes public confidence in the news media, particularly the business news media. The point being that we are not stenographers, and if a CEO blatantly is blatantly untruthful or dishonest, we have no obligation to serve as his megaphone.”
OLD Media Moves
Why do biz journalists use Byrne as a source?
June 10, 2009
Business journalist Gary Weiss wonders on his blog why Overstock.com CEO Patrick Byrne, a frequent critic of business journalism, is used as a source for stories.
Weiss writes, “One really has to wonder what motivated the Salt Lake City Tribune, in this story, to buttonhole Byrne of all people to pontificate on corporate management of earnings releases. It’s just embarassing. Good heavens, a little elementary research would have found ample material on the web on how Byrne has engineered earnings at Overstock, much of it by white collar crime-fighter Sam Antar.
“For instance, Antar pointed out in some detail in his blog last year how Byrne manipulated the earnings announcement in the first quarter of 2008.
“While the Trib’s sloppiness is not comparable with the atrocious media coverage of Pegasus Wireless or Biovail, it’s the kind of thing that erodes public confidence in the news media, particularly the business news media. The point being that we are not stenographers, and if a CEO blatantly is blatantly untruthful or dishonest, we have no obligation to serve as his megaphone.”
Read more here.
Media News
WSJ’s Tucker: Gershkovich shows importance of free press
March 28, 2024
Media News
Read-a-thon recognizes one year in jail for WSJ’s Gershkovich
March 28, 2024
Media News
Rosen departs Business Insider for a new opportunity
March 28, 2024
Media News
Why Evan Gershkovich’s case is so important
March 28, 2024
Media News
Taylor joins Bloomberg’s municipal finance team
March 28, 2024
Subscribe to TBN
Receive updates about new stories in the industry daily or weekly.