Now that New York Times columnist Paul Krugman has won a Nobel Prize in economics, David Warsh of Economicprinicipals.com wonders when he will win a Pulitzer for his commentary.
Washington Post business columnist Steve Pearlstein won a Pulitzer this year for commentary.
Warsh writes, “Paul Samuelson last week told Catherine Rampell of the Times, ‘I praise today’s prize as being deserving and even overdue, but more than that I reproach the Pulitzer committee, which owed him at least a couple of prizes in the past. Paul Krugman is the only columnist in the United States who has had it right on almost every count since the beginning.’
“True enough, as far as it goes. But in journalism, as in economics, being right is not all that counts. Intellectual honesty requires something more complicated than that: a systematic marshalling, of not just your own arguments, but the arguments of those with whom you disagree, all the arguments, not just some. The Nobel prize attests that Krugman met that test with flying colors in his work on trade.
“But then formal methods in economics are designed to lead in that direction. The goal in news is something far more provisional than proof. Still, professional standards of fairness require that take your opponents’ views into account and state them as clearly as possible along with your own, even within the limits of a 750-word column, or a series of columns over time. It’s not just what you say, but the way that you say it.”
OLD Media Moves
Krugman next in line for Pulitzer?
October 20, 2008
Now that New York Times columnist Paul Krugman has won a Nobel Prize in economics, David Warsh of Economicprinicipals.com wonders when he will win a Pulitzer for his commentary.
Washington Post business columnist Steve Pearlstein won a Pulitzer this year for commentary.
Warsh writes, “Paul Samuelson last week told Catherine Rampell of the Times, ‘I praise today’s prize as being deserving and even overdue, but more than that I reproach the Pulitzer committee, which owed him at least a couple of prizes in the past. Paul Krugman is the only columnist in the United States who has had it right on almost every count since the beginning.’
“True enough, as far as it goes. But in journalism, as in economics, being right is not all that counts. Intellectual honesty requires something more complicated than that: a systematic marshalling, of not just your own arguments, but the arguments of those with whom you disagree, all the arguments, not just some. The Nobel prize attests that Krugman met that test with flying colors in his work on trade.
“But then formal methods in economics are designed to lead in that direction. The goal in news is something far more provisional than proof. Still, professional standards of fairness require that take your opponents’ views into account and state them as clearly as possible along with your own, even within the limits of a 750-word column, or a series of columns over time. It’s not just what you say, but the way that you say it.”
Read more here.
Highlighted News
Swisher to receive Lifetime Achievement Webby
April 23, 2024
Media News
Berke’s cannabis newsletter nearing 15,000 subscribers
April 23, 2024
Highlighted News
Qwoted 100 PR Superstar: Amanda Kruse of UpSpring
April 23, 2024
Media News
Parker named Bloomberg ME of economy/government coverage
April 23, 2024
Media News
Bloomberg’s Cortez moving to Washington
April 23, 2024
Subscribe to TBN
Receive updates about new stories in the industry daily or weekly.