Barron's cover story on oil bubble popping is nuts
June 23, 2008
TheStreet.com media critic Marek Fuchs writes Monday that the cover story in the latest issue of Barron’s that argues that the oil price bubble is about to burst is faulty in its premise.
Fuchs writes, “‘Oil Bubble: When It Will Pop and Why,’ it said, accompanied by a big, black, oily bubble. I settled into my chair, ready to read a top-flight intellectual case for why the oil market was set to tumble.
“Because you, the savvy investor, must consider future movements in the prices of stocks, commodities and markets, that’s the type of journalism that works to your advantage. The other type, which is unfortunately more prevalent, is journalism that presents itself as courageous despite being rife with caveats and escape hatches. The latter type of writing suggests the writer has spent more energy protecting himself from the consequences of being wrong than figuring out what is right.
“So, I turned the page and saw this headline: ‘Bye, Bubble? The Price of Oil May Be Peaking.’
“This was the first sign of trouble. Barron’s had backpedaled from predicting oil’s demise to questioning its demise, suggesting the price ‘may’ be peaking. That said, this could just have been overly cautious headline writing.”
OLD Media Moves
Barron's cover story on oil bubble popping is nuts
June 23, 2008
TheStreet.com media critic Marek Fuchs writes Monday that the cover story in the latest issue of Barron’s that argues that the oil price bubble is about to burst is faulty in its premise.
Fuchs writes, “‘Oil Bubble: When It Will Pop and Why,’ it said, accompanied by a big, black, oily bubble. I settled into my chair, ready to read a top-flight intellectual case for why the oil market was set to tumble.
“Because you, the savvy investor, must consider future movements in the prices of stocks, commodities and markets, that’s the type of journalism that works to your advantage. The other type, which is unfortunately more prevalent, is journalism that presents itself as courageous despite being rife with caveats and escape hatches. The latter type of writing suggests the writer has spent more energy protecting himself from the consequences of being wrong than figuring out what is right.
“So, I turned the page and saw this headline: ‘Bye, Bubble? The Price of Oil May Be Peaking.’
“This was the first sign of trouble. Barron’s had backpedaled from predicting oil’s demise to questioning its demise, suggesting the price ‘may’ be peaking. That said, this could just have been overly cautious headline writing.”
But it wasn’t. Read more here.Â
Media News
SABEW elects new board members, Nelson as president
April 24, 2024
Media News
WSJ receives first Peabody Award nomination
April 24, 2024
Media News
NAHJ seeks to start biz journalism task force
April 24, 2024
Media News
Bagchee returning to CNBC to run international
April 24, 2024
Media News
Hillman Prizes awarded to Quartz, Bloomberg Businessweek
April 24, 2024
Subscribe to TBN
Receive updates about new stories in the industry daily or weekly.